Summary of Judgement
The petitioner applied for the Civil Services Examination 2014 and qualified through all stages, but was declared "temporarily unfit" due to high BMI. He missed the re-medical test after the final result was published, assuming he was out of the race. Later, he found his name on a reserve list but was not allocated a service. He sought legal recourse to be treated similarly to another candidate, Mr. K. Rajashekhara Reddy, who had been granted relief after missing his re-medical test. The court granted a limited relief, allowing the petitioner a re-medical test without seniority benefits if he passes.
Introduction
- Petitioner participated in the Civil Services Examination 2014 and qualified in Prelims, Mains, and Interview.
- Declared "temporarily unfit" due to high BMI after medical examination.
- Re-medical test scheduled but not attended by the petitioner.
Final Results and Subsequent Events
- UPSC published final results on 04.07.2015; petitioner not listed.
- Petitioner missed the re-medical test scheduled for 14.07.2015, assuming the process was complete.
Discovery of Reserve List
- Reserve list published on 19.01.2016; petitioner secured rank 93.
- Candidates below the petitioner's rank were allocated service.
Legal Proceedings
- Petitioner approached the Central Administrative Tribunal, Patna; application dismissed.
- Filed Writ Petition before the High Court of Patna.
Similar Case Reference
- Case of Mr. K. Rajashekhara Reddy allowed by High Court, Telangana; re-medical directed.
- Supreme Court upheld re-medical and directed consideration for appointment.
Petitioner's Subsequent Actions
- Petitioner withdrew Writ Petition and made representation to authorities for similar treatment.
- Authorities confirmed petitioner's status as "Unfit for all Services."
Present Writ Petition
- Petitioner seeks service allocation with benefits or a re-medical examination.
- Court rejects service allocation but considers re-medical examination.
Court's Decision
- Petitioner missed re-medical opportunity in 2015.
- Recognizes similarity with Mr. K. Rajashekhara Reddy's case.
Grant of Limited Relief
- Court grants re-medical test within four weeks.
- Petitioner not entitled to appointment in the 2014 Batch or seniority benefits if he qualifies.
Conclusion
- Exceptional case, not to be treated as precedent.
- Petition partly allowed; no order as to costs.
Case Title: Rakshit Shivam Prakash Versus. Union of India and Anr.
Citation: 2024 LawText (SC) (8) 25
Case Number: [Writ Petition (Civil) No. 890/2023]
Date of Decision: 2024-08-02