Bombay High Court Grants Anticipatory Bail in Vehicular Dispute Turned Fatal Assault Case. Court notes lack of criminal intent and antecedents; sets strict conditions for bail to ensure investigation integrity.


CASE NOTE & SUMMARY

The High Court of Judicature at Bombay heard an anticipatory bail application from Ganesh Sitaram Gawari, accused of murder under IPC Section 302 r/w 34. The incident arose from a vehicular dispute leading to an assault on Lalchand Ramdeo Pal, who later died from injuries. The court, noting the lack of criminal antecedents and no evidence of intent to kill, granted bail under specific conditions.

Introduction

  • Case: Anticipatory Bail Application No. 1723 of 2016
  • Applicant: Ganesh Sitaram Gawari
  • Respondent: State of Maharashtra
  • Coram: Mrs. Mridula Bhatkar, J.
  • Date: 10th January 2017

Case Background

  • Incident Date: 06/05/2016
  • Complainant: Vigunath Raghuvir Pal
  • Deceased: Lalchand Ramdeo Pal
  • Allegations: Assault leading to death due to a vehicular dispute.

Arguments

  • Applicant’s Counsel:
    • No intent to kill; assault was spontaneous.
    • Applicant available to police since the incident.
  • Prosecution:
    • Charges of murder under IPC Section 302.
    • Deceased named the applicant in a statement.
    • The applicant was absconding.

Court Observations

  • FIR & Witness Statements: Reviewed.
  • Post-Mortem Report: Death due to septicemia from intestinal perforation caused by the assault.
  • Context: Sudden quarrel, no weapon used, no criminal history of the applicant, no mens rea (intent to kill).

Court Order

  • Bail Granted:
    • P.R. Bond of Rs. 50,000 with sureties.
    • Cooperate with police investigation.
    • No tampering with evidence or pressurizing the complainant.
    • No further criminal activities.
  • Conclusion: Application disposed of on these terms.

Final Disposition

  • The application for anticipatory bail was granted under specified conditions to ensure the applicant’s cooperation with the investigation while mitigating risks of tampering or further criminal conduct.

Citation: 2017 LawText (BOM) (1) 101

Case Number: ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION NO.1723 OF 2016

Date of Decision: 2017-01-10

Case Title: Ganesh Sitaram Gawari Versus State of Maharashtra

Before Judge: MRS.MRIDULA BHATKAR, J.

Advocate(s): Mr.Aniket Nikam, Advocate i/b. Aashhish Satpute, Advocate for the Applicant. Mr.Rajan Salvi, APP for the State/Respondent.

Appellant: Ganesh Sitaram Gawari

Respondent: State of Maharashtra