High Court Allows Writ Petition, Quashes Caste Certificate Rejection and Directs Issuance of Validity Certificate to 'Mang' Scheduled Caste Claimant. Documentary Evidence from 1932 Prevails Over Alleged Conversion Issues

Nature of Litigation: Writ Petition challenging administrative order rejecting caste certificate claim

Remedy Sought

Petitioner seeking quashing of order dated 27/09/2023 and direction for issuance of caste validity certificate

Filing Reason

District Caste Certificate Verification Committee rejected Petitioner's caste claim to 'Mang' Scheduled Caste

Previous Decisions

Committee rejected claim based on Christian entries in documents and alleged conversion to Christianity

Issues

Whether the Petitioner's caste claim to 'Mang' Scheduled Caste was validly rejected by the Scrutiny Committee Whether documentary evidence from 1932 and 1934 establishing 'Mang' caste should prevail over later Christian entries

Submissions/Arguments

Petitioner argued he belongs to 'Mang' Scheduled Caste with documentary evidence from 1932 showing great grandfather's caste as 'Mang' Respondents argued rejection was justified due to Christian entries and alleged conversion of father and grandfather to Christianity

Ratio Decidendi

Pre-constitutional documentary evidence from 1932 and 1934 establishing 'Mang' caste must be given primacy over later entries suggesting conversion -- The Committee failed to properly evaluate documentary evidence and existing validity certificate issued to relative -- Mere Christian entries in some documents do not automatically invalidate caste claim when pre-constitutional evidence exists

Judgment Excerpts

The Petitioner has submitted a proposal for validation of caste claim along with document i.e. School Leaving Certificate issued by Headmaster of Akola Municipal Corporation Primary School No.4, Akola to great grandfather of the Petitioner namely 'Ganpat Bhika' dated 10/08/1932 In spite of this explanation, the Caste claim of the Petitioner came to be rejected holding that his grandfather and father appeared to have accepted Christianity It is a matter of record that there is a document of 1932, which is school leaving certificate, wherein the caste of the great grandfather of the Petitioner is shown as 'Mang'

Procedural History

Petitioner submitted caste validation proposal with documents -- Matter referred to Vigilance Cell -- Committee issued notice based on Vigilance Report -- Petitioner submitted reply with additional documents -- Committee rejected claim on 27/09/2023 -- Petitioner filed Writ Petition on 2024 -- Court heard matter at admission stage by consent -- Judgment reserved on 23/02/2026 -- Judgment pronounced on 26/02/2026